CFE Intervener Factum in the Ontario Court of Appeal - In response to an unknown person posting accusations on Reddit that Ottawa-Carleton District School Board officials have failed to report incidents involving stifling investigations and ignoring instances of racism, the Board sought a “Norwich Order” – essentially an unmasking order to compel Reddit to provide any email addresses, phone numbers, location data and other identifying information about the user whom it thinks may be an employee and who many see as an important whistleblower.
The Centre for Free Expression intervener factum made three submissions. First, Norwich Orders must not be allowed to be a tool of retaliation against whistleblowers. Second, when considering an unmasking order, courts must consider the free expression implications of de-anonymizing a person’s online activity. Third, the fact that Reddit’s terms of service state that the company will comply with lawful requests does not diminish a person’s privacy interest in maintaining their online anonymity. It is inherently circular reasoning to use the fact that a company will comply with lawful orders to justify making such an order.
In a recent opinion piece in the Toronto Star, staff journalist Justin Ling argues that to improve productivity, Canada needs to tolerate more corruption. This is nonsense – in fact the reverse is true. As he says, simply creating more bureaucracy in response to each scandal doesn’t work.