Skip to main content

Court Submissions

Court Submission October 27, 2026

Reddit Inc v. Ottawa-Carleton District School Board, ONCA file COA-25-CV-1729

CFE Intervener Factum in the Ontario Court of Appeal - In response to an unknown person posting accusations on Reddit that Ottawa-Carleton District School Board officials have failed to report incidents involving stifling investigations and ignoring instances of racism, the Board sought a “Norwich Order” – essentially an unmasking order to compel Reddit to provide any email addresses, phone numbers, location data and other identifying information about the user whom it thinks may be an employee and who many see as an important whistleblower. The Centre for Free Expression intervener factum made three submissions. First, Norwich Orders must not be allowed to be a tool of retaliation against whistleblowers. Second, when considering an unmasking order, courts must consider the free expression implications of de-anonymizing a person’s online activity. Third, the fact that Reddit’s terms of service state that the company will comply with lawful requests does not diminish a person’s privacy interest in maintaining their online anonymity. It is inherently circular reasoning to use the fact that a company will comply with lawful orders to justify making such an order.
Court Submission June 10, 2026

Government of Saskatchewan as Represented by the Minister of Education v. UR Pride Centre for Sexuality and Gender Diversity, SCC Court File No. 41979

CFE Intervener Factum in the Supreme Court of Canada – UR Pride challenged the constitutionality of a Saskatchewan policy that parental consent was required if students under the age of 16 requested that schools use preferred first names and pronouns. In response, Saskatchewan amended its Education Act, incorporating the policy into law and invoked the Charter’s notwithstanding clause (s. 33). UR Pride sought a declaration that the legislation is unconstitutional. Saskatchewan argued that once it incorporated s. 33, the issue of constitutionality is moot and the court cannot issue a declaratory judgment. In its factum CFE makes three submissions. First, s. 33 should be interpreted in light of the public’s right to be informed in a democracy. Second, the public’s right to be informed pre-dates the Charter and is a throughline in the Supreme Court’s interpretation of Charter provisions, most notably ss. 2(b), 3 and 4. Third, because the invocation of the notwithstanding clause has to be renewed every five years, meaning there will be an election that allows the public to defeat a government if it objects to the government’s use of s. 33, judicial declarations are necessary information if the public is to be an effective check against misuse of s. 33.
Court Submission April 24, 2026

Cynthia Prescott, et al. v. Benchwood Builders Inc., et al., SCC Court File No. : 41794

CFE Intervener Factum in the Supreme Court of Canada – This appeal is a significant test of Ontario’s anti-SLAPP legislation, balancing corporate reputation with the right of consumers to share online feedback. Originally the homeowners’ anti-SLAPP motion to dismiss the defamation suit brought by Benchwood Builders (the plaintiff) was granted, but later it was revered by the Ontario Court of Appeal. The crucial “weighing” test under the legislation is that the plaintiff, to avoid having the case dismissed, must show that the harm caused by the expression at issue is “sufficiently serious” to outweigh the public interest in protecting the defendant's expression. The plaintiff must also meet a “merits” test satisfying the court that it was seriously harmed by the expression and that the defendant has “no valid defense.” The merits stage often requires a complex and resource-intensive analysis. The Centre for Free Expression was granted leave to intervene. CFE submits that the motion’s judge can expedite anti-SLAPP cases, once the required public interest test has been met by the defendant in the underlying case, by addressing the “weighing” test first. If it is not found in the plaintiff’s favour, the motions judge can be relieved, or can deal with more cursorily, with the often more complex and resource-intensive merits-based analysis. CFE also submits that corporate plaintiffs alleging defamation must show a link between the impugned expression and pecuniary loss to meet their burden of demonstrative “serious harm.”
Court Submission December 26, 2025

Facebook Inc. v. Privacy Commissioner of Canada, SCC Court File No. : 41538

CFE Intervener Factum in the Supreme Court of Canada – This appeal concerns the scope of the obligations of meaningful consent and safeguarding according to Canada’s Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA). CFE submits three points in this intervener factum: (1) evidence of subjective expectations of privacy, rather than those of a reasonable person, has no role to play in determining whether meaningful consent was provided under PIPEDA; (2) users’ reasonable expectations of privacy on digital platforms will generally be high; and (3) meaningful consent to the use or disclosure of personal information on digital platforms requires that the platform clearly inform the user of the specific purposes for which the information may be used or disclosed, prior to such use or disclosure.
Court Submission November 25, 2025

Democracy Watch v. Attorney General of Canada, SCC Court File No. : 41576

CFE Intervener Factum in the Supreme Court of Canada - In this factum, CFE submits that citizens’ access — and particularly, public interest litigants’ access — to judicial review remedies is a fundamental feature of the democratic dialogue in Canada. Absent a robust remedial comparison, judicial review applicants are at risk of being rerouted to inadequate alternative processes, including political processes with which they cannot meaningfully engage.
Court Submission August 5, 2025

Knauff v. Ontario (Human Rights Tribunal) et al., ONCA, Court File COA-25-OM-0074

Joint Intervener Factum of ACTO/ Animal Justice/CCLA/CFE/Democracy Watch/ISAC  – Ontario Court of Appeal. The issue is to update the test for leave to appeal decisions of the Ontario Divisional Court. We argue the test for leave to appeal established by the Ontario Court of Appeal in its 1972 Sault Dock decision should be refreshed to reflect the evolution of administrative, constitutional, and human rights law over the past 50 years, and the role of the Divisional Court in response to those changes. Based on key legal developments in recent decades, we suggest there is a need for the leave test to focus on the criterion of “public importance.” We propose a non-exhaustive list of factors that this Court ought to consider when deciding whether to grant leave to appeal decisions of the Divisional Court.